Mapping the Swamp Ward
“Swamp Ward” is a vernacular or local name for the area of Kingston that lies north of Princess Street to the west of the Inner Harbour — that is, it runs up along the west shore of the Great Cataraqui River to Belle Island.
When I initiated the Swamp Ward and Inner Harbour History Project in 2015, I drew the boundaries of research at Queen Street north to Stephen, and Division Street east to the Great Cataraqui River. This area has an integrity in terms of its cultural and built heritage, and it makes sense as a neighbourhood from today’s perspective. But the term “Swamp Ward” is not on any map, and so the boundaries of the district have been one of the project’s central questions — along with the origins and meanings of the designation “Swamp Ward.”
The name’s origins are unclear although indeed the area was quite swampy, more so in the past before fill (often garbage) evened out the wetter areas. Montreal Street was built along the stable shoreline of the river, and everything east of it was (and is) on the floodplain. Historian Jennifer McKendry has found newspaper mention of the term “Swamp Ward” as early as 1871, where it was used as a (pejorative) synonym for the Cataraqui Ward – an electoral district. But SWIHHP interviews reveal that in living memory, the term has been more clearly identified with particular cultural and community traits and locations than with specific boundaries. At least until the 1970s when the Inner Harbour deindustrialized, the Swamp Ward had a strong working class culture and was the first point of arrival for most immigrants from other countries. Montreal Street between Raglan Road and Charles Street was an important commercial area and thus the main street of the neighbourhood. And Robert Meek & St. John’s Schools (both now closed) were neighbourhood hubs. “Swamp Warders” had to cross Princess Street for high school, to go to the cathedral, or sometimes to work, but they often defined themselves in distinction from people and neighbourhoods south of Princess. People who lived south of Princess did the opposite. Thus the valence of the term “Swamp Ward” was closely tied to who used it. By the 1980s, interviews suggest, younger people in the area no longer seemed to be using the term “Swamp Ward”; the more common name was “North of Princess.” When members of St. Paul’s Church started up the Swamp Ward Festival in the 1980s, the name was chosen deliberately to renew pride in a name and a neighbourhood they understood to be stigmatized.
In contributing to the resuscitation of the name “Swamp Ward” in the twenty-first century, I may have contributed to muddying the waters (as it were) about the part of town it applies to. My improved understanding of the topography and cultural history of the area from many interviews and archival research now leads me to suggest now that properly speaking the Swamp Ward only refers to the area east of and including Montreal Street. After all, for example, the height of land at Sydenham Street or McBurney (Skeleton) Park could hardly be called swampy. But SWIHHP will continue to explore the larger area as defined at its inception in 2015. This larger area shares experiences of immigration, labour, deindustrialization, and, nowadays, gentrification; all of it has been neglected by historians and public commemoration and education.
To hear people from the neighbourhood talking about what the term “Swamp Ward” means to them, listen to the first episode of Stories of the Swamp Ward.
Kingston in 1875
In 1875, the Cataraqui Ward took Montreal Street as its western boundary, and Princess as its southern boundary.
The close-up reveals industry, wharves, and train tracks along the river. The tracks marked “proposed” and running through the water were never built, but indeed today’s Douglas Fluhrer Park is essentially infill between the train track and what was then the shore. Note too the marshes in which a tannery was later built north of River Street.
Kingston in 1966
By 1966, the ward boundaries have changed. Cataraqui Ward now goes west to Division, and the St. Lawrence Ward has been carved out of the bottom of it. (Today’s district, King’s Town, goes all the way to John Counter Boulevard in the north and extends south of Princess along the water.)
Mapping the Swamp Ward in 2017
In interviews conducted from 2015 to 2017, only Princess Street and the river appeared as consistent boundaries of the Swamp Ward; the north and west boundaries were understood in various ways. Only a couple of people I interviewed identified “Swamp Ward” as merely a synonym of “Cataraqui Ward.” To represent the ways people understood or used the term, I asked Queen’s map librarian Francine Berish to make a map. Interestingly, the mapping program Francine used could not easily cope with gradations of colour – it wanted a hard boundary where I was looking for “fade to white” at the edges. But the darker orange is if you will the heart of the Swamp Ward, and beyond that fewer people tended to apply the term. The dark orange area does match fairly well with the ward boundaries of 1875.
— Laura Murray